Start by pulling the cardboard tokens
The plastic token set is a direct replacement, not an addition. The supplied product information states that these premium plastic tokens replace the cardboard Freeze, Riddle, and VP tokens from DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum. Before you open the bag, separate those three cardboard types from the rest of the game components so the swap is clean and reversible.
Keep the cardboard tokens in a small bag or the game box. They are not part of this set, but holding onto them gives you a fallback if a plastic token is ever misplaced and makes it easier to pass the game along later with its original components.
What the plastic token set contains
- DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum — Plastic Tokens & Bag: 6 Freeze Tokens, 8 Riddle Tokens, and 40 VP Tokens Match each count to the cardboard tokens you remove so you can confirm the swap is complete before play.

DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum — Plastic Tokens & Bag - DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum — Plastic Tokens & Bag: Premium The Riddler bag with high-quality printing The bag is part of the set, not packaging, so plan where it lives in your game box or on the table.
Set up the tokens for an Arkham Asylum session
- Clear the table area for three token piles: Set out separate piles for Freeze, Riddle, and VP tokens. The supplied counts are 6, 8, and 40, so you can verify each pile at a glance.
- Put the VP tokens where all players can reach them: With 40 VP tokens, this is the largest pile. A central spot keeps scoring and VP tracking from turning into a reach across the table.
- Keep Freeze and Riddle tokens near the cards that use them: The supplied information does not describe which specific cards or locations these tokens attach to, so place them where your group already handles those effects during play.
- Use The Riddler bag for transport, not as a randomizer: The supplied information describes the bag as premium with high-quality printing. It does not state that the bag is intended for blind draws, so treat it as a carry and storage bag rather than a game mechanic.
Use the bag to speed up pack-up
The Riddler bag earns its place at the end of the night. Gather the 6 Freeze Tokens, 8 Riddle Tokens, and 40 VP Tokens into their separate piles, then drop them into the bag. Because the set is plastic, the tokens are designed as a durable upgrade over the cardboard originals, but the supplied information does not include care instructions, so avoid stacking heavy game boxes on top of the bag.
If your group plays Arkham Asylum often, the bag also shortens setup. Keep the tokens in the bag between sessions and pour them out into the three piles at the start of the next game. That is the practical version of arkham asylum token bag use: fewer loose pieces rattling around the box and a faster path from shelf to table.
Storage choices that keep the set together
- Bag inside the game box: The simplest option. Confirm the box lid closes without pressure on the tokens or the bag, since the supplied information does not list a storage box or tray for this set.
- Bag in a separate small game bag: Useful if your Arkham Asylum box is already full. Keep the bag with the base game so the replacement tokens travel with the cards they support.
- Tokens loose in a divided tray: Works if you prefer visible piles. Keep the bag nearby so the set stays together and the tokens do not migrate into other games.
Plastic tokens vs the cardboard originals
The supplied information frames this set as a premium plastic replacement for the cardboard Freeze, Riddle, and VP tokens. It does not include dimensions, weight, or a material specification beyond plastic, so the comparison below stays with what is confirmed.
- Plastic set: 6 Freeze, 8 Riddle, and 40 VP tokens in plastic, plus The Riddler bag. Released September 2025.
- Cardboard originals: The tokens that come with DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum. This set replaces them, so the cardboard versions are not needed once the swap is complete.
What to check before you buy
This set is made for DC Deck-Building Game: Arkham Asylum. The supplied information does not state compatibility with other DC Deck-Building Game titles, so do not assume the tokens will substitute for tokens in a different version. The set is listed at USD 18.59 against a catalog comparison price of USD 29.99, and the catalog lists a Standard variant.
If you are deciding between keeping the cardboard tokens and upgrading, the practical question is how often the game reaches your table. Frequent players get the most from a plastic set and a dedicated bag; occasional players may find the cardboard originals sufficient. The supplied information does not include care instructions or a warranty, so treat the bag and tokens as you would any game component and store them away from heavy pressure.


